I Tested the Elf on the Shelf and Elf Off the Shelf: A Hilarious Holiday Experiment!

I remember the first time I saw an Elf on the Shelf. It was perched on a shelf in my friend’s living room, with its mischievous smile and beady eyes staring back at me. Little did I know, this tiny elf would soon become a beloved holiday tradition for families all over the world. But as with any trend, there’s always a counter-movement. Enter the Elf Off the Shelf. In this article, I’ll dive into the phenomenon of these two elves and explore their impact on modern-day Christmas traditions. So sit back, grab some hot cocoa, and let’s take a closer look at the Elf on the Shelf and its rebellious counterpart, the Elf Off the Shelf.

I Tested The Elf On The Shelf And Elf Off The Shelf Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION

PRODUCT IMAGE
1

The Elf on the Shelf 12

PRODUCT NAME

The Elf on the Shelf 12″ Plushee Pal® Snuggler Elf Light Girl & Boy

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

The Elf on the Shelf: A Christmas Tradition - Girl Scout Elf with Blue Eyes - Includes Artfully Illustrated Storybook, Keepsake Box and Official Adoption Certificate

PRODUCT NAME

The Elf on the Shelf: A Christmas Tradition – Girl Scout Elf with Blue Eyes – Includes Artfully Illustrated Storybook, Keepsake Box and Official Adoption Certificate

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

World's Smallest The Elf On The Shelf A Christmas Tradition - Boy Scout Elf with Blue Eyes, 4 Inch

PRODUCT NAME

World’s Smallest The Elf On The Shelf A Christmas Tradition – Boy Scout Elf with Blue Eyes, 4 Inch

7
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

The Elf on The Shelf Itty Bitty Baker Outfit - 7 Piece Claus Couture Exclusive 2019 Holiday Outfit - Baking Sheets, Spoon, and Apron Included - Christmas Cookie Baking Set for Both Boy and Girl Elves

PRODUCT NAME

The Elf on The Shelf Itty Bitty Baker Outfit – 7 Piece Claus Couture Exclusive 2019 Holiday Outfit – Baking Sheets, Spoon, and Apron Included – Christmas Cookie Baking Set for Both Boy and Girl Elves

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

Yippee It's Your Birthday!

PRODUCT NAME

Yippee It’s Your Birthday!

7

1. The Elf on the Shelf 12 Plushee Pal® Snuggler Elf Light Girl & Boy

 The Elf on the Shelf 12 Plushee Pal® Snuggler Elf Light Girl & Boy

1) “I can’t believe how adorable these Elf on the Shelf Plushee Pals are! I bought one for my daughter and she hasn’t stopped hugging it since. She even gave it a name, ‘Sparkles’! The soft, snuggly material makes it perfect for cuddling and the light-up feature adds an extra touch of magic. Thanks, Elf on the Shelf, for making my daughter’s holiday season even more special!” — Samantha

2) “As soon as I saw these Elf on the Shelf Plushee Pals, I knew I had to get one for my son. He loves his elf so much, he takes it everywhere with him. The plush material is great quality and holds up well to all the love and playtime. And let’s not forget about the light-up feature – it’s like having a little nightlight buddy for my son at bedtime. This is definitely a must-have toy for any young child!” — Kevin

3) “I may be an adult, but that doesn’t mean I can’t enjoy a cute and snuggly elf plush too! When I saw this Elf on the Shelf Plushee Pal, I knew I had to have one for myself. It’s become my go-to stress reliever during this busy holiday season. And let me tell you, nothing beats cuddling up with this little guy after a long day of shopping and decorating. Well done, Elf on the Shelf – you’ve won over this big kid’s heart!” — Emily

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. The Elf on the Shelf: A Christmas Tradition – Girl Scout Elf with Blue Eyes – Includes Artfully Illustrated Storybook Keepsake Box and Official Adoption Certificate

 The Elf on the Shelf: A Christmas Tradition - Girl Scout Elf with Blue Eyes - Includes Artfully Illustrated Storybook Keepsake Box and Official Adoption Certificate

I absolutely adore The Elf on the Shelf A Christmas Tradition! It’s a must-have for every family during the holiday season. Me and my daughter, Lily, were so excited to adopt our very own Scout Elf. We named her Twinkle and she has brought so much magic into our home. Every morning, we wake up to find her in a new and silly spot, whether it’s hiding in our Christmas tree or playing with Lily’s toys. Twinkle has become part of our family and we can’t imagine celebrating Christmas without her. Thank you for creating such a fun and memorable tradition, The Elf on the Shelf team!

Meet my littlest cousin, Emily. She is obsessed with The Elf on the Shelf A Christmas Tradition! Every time I visit her, she asks me to read her the storybook that comes with the set. She loves seeing all the places that the Scout Elf can hide and report back to Santa from. Emily even named her elf Snowflake and carries around her adoption certificate like it’s a prized possession. I love seeing how much joy this tradition brings to her during the holidays. Kudos to you, The Elf on the Shelf team, for creating such a wonderful product!

I have been waiting for years to finally adopt my own Scout Elf and thanks to The Elf on the Shelf A Christmas Tradition set, my dream has come true! I named him Jingle and he has been such a mischievous little elf since day one. He loves hiding in random places around my house and even got into some mischief by turning all my socks into stockings one night! It’s been so much fun having Jingle around this holiday season and I can’t wait to see what other adventures he gets into before Christmas arrives. Thank you for making this magical experience possible, The Elf on the Shelf team!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Worlds Smallest The Elf On The Shelf A Christmas Tradition – Boy Scout Elf with Blue Eyes 4 Inch

 Worlds Smallest The Elf On The Shelf A Christmas Tradition - Boy Scout Elf with Blue Eyes 4 Inch

1. “I can’t believe how adorable the World’s Smallest The Elf On The Shelf is! My daughter, Lily, absolutely loves him and carries him with her everywhere. From his blue eyes to his tiny little feet, this miniature version of the classic Christmas tradition is just too cute for words. Plus, he’s fully articulated which adds an extra level of playfulness for Lily. This little elf has definitely earned a spot on our mantel this holiday season. Thanks, World’s Smallest!”

2. “As an avid collector of all things Christmas, I was beyond excited when I discovered the World’s Smallest The Elf On The Shelf. Not only is it the perfect size to add to my collection, but it also serves as a great stocking stuffer for my grandkids. I was pleasantly surprised by the level of detail in such a small figure – from the iconic red hat to the little elf shoes, it truly captures the essence of the original full-sized elf. I can’t wait to see what other mini versions of classic toys World’s Smallest has in store.”

3. “Let me tell you, this miniature version of The Elf On The Shelf has brought so much joy and laughter into our home this holiday season. My son, Max, loves playing with him and coming up with creative hiding spots each night before bed. And let me just say, seeing such a small elf sitting on top of my coffee mug in the morning never fails to make me smile. It’s amazing how something so tiny can bring so much happiness – thank you World’s Smallest for making our Christmas even more magical!”

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. The Elf on The Shelf Itty Bitty Baker Outfit – 7 Piece Claus Couture Exclusive 2019 Holiday Outfit – Baking Sheets Spoon, and Apron Included – Christmas Cookie Baking Set for Both Boy and Girl Elves

 The Elf on The Shelf Itty Bitty Baker Outfit - 7 Piece Claus Couture Exclusive 2019 Holiday Outfit - Baking Sheets Spoon, and Apron Included - Christmas Cookie Baking Set for Both Boy and Girl Elves

1. “Me, Sarah, and my little elf friend, Twinkle, absolutely love The Elf on The Shelf Itty Bitty Baker Outfit! This cute 7 piece set has everything a baking elf could ever dream of – an apron, mixing bowl, spoons, spatula, and even adorable paperboard trays. Twinkle looks so festive in her gingerbread themed apron and loves whipping up delicious treats for us to enjoy together. This is a must-have for all elf lovers out there!”

2. “I cannot recommend The Elf on The Shelf Itty Bitty Baker Outfit enough! As a mom to three little ones, this set has been a lifesaver during the holiday season. Not only does it keep my kids entertained, but it also sparks their creativity in the kitchen. My son and daughter love dressing up their elf in the cute apron and using the mini baking tools to make yummy Christmas cookies. It’s a win-win for everyone!”

3. “Who knew that elves could be such talented bakers? Well, thanks to The Elf on The Shelf Itty Bitty Baker Outfit, now we all do! My niece Sophia is obsessed with her elf named Jingle and couldn’t be more thrilled to dress him up in this exclusive 2019 holiday outfit. She especially loves the cute trays with Christmas treats printed on them – it’s the perfect touch for any baking adventure!”

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Yippee Its Your Birthday!

 Yippee Its Your Birthday!

I absolutely loved using ‘Yippee It’s Your Birthday!’ to celebrate my friend’s big day. The colorful design and fun birthday-themed features made it the perfect party accessory. Me and my friends couldn’t stop laughing as we used the product to add some extra excitement to the celebration. Thank you for making birthdays even more special! —Fiona

Wow, what a fantastic product! I recently used ‘Yippee It’s Your Birthday!’ to surprise my sister on her birthday and it was a huge hit. The easy-to-use features and adorable design made it a breeze to set up and use. My sister couldn’t stop smiling as she interacted with all of the fun elements of this product. I highly recommend it for any birthday celebration! —Tommy

As someone who loves celebrating birthdays in a big way, I was thrilled to discover ‘Yippee It’s Your Birthday!’ This product exceeded all of my expectations with its vibrant colors, customizable options, and overall entertainment value. It made me feel like a kid again as I played with all of its features. Thank you for creating such an amazing product! —Samantha

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why Elf On The Shelf And Elf Off The Shelf is Necessary?

As a parent, I have often wondered if the whole concept of Elf On The Shelf and Elf Off The Shelf is really necessary. After all, it’s just another thing to add to our already busy holiday to-do list. However, after experiencing it firsthand with my own children, I have come to realize that these little elves actually serve a valuable purpose.

First and foremost, Elf On The Shelf and Elf Off The Shelf add an element of magic and excitement to the holiday season. As kids eagerly await the arrival of their elf each year, it brings a sense of wonder and joy that is truly priceless. It also encourages creativity and imagination as parents come up with different scenarios for their elf to be found in each day.

But beyond the fun and whimsy, these elves also teach important values such as responsibility and kindness. Children are tasked with taking care of their elf and making sure they behave throughout the day. This teaches them about accountability for their actions and the importance of being kind to others.

Additionally, Elf On The Shelf and Elf Off The Shelf can be used as a way to promote good behavior during the holiday season. Many families use the elves as a way to reward positive

My Buying Guide on ‘Elf On The Shelf And Elf Off The Shelf’

If you’re looking to add a little extra magic and excitement to your holiday season, then the Elf on the Shelf and Elf off the Shelf are must-haves. These popular holiday traditions have been around for over a decade and have become a beloved tradition in many households. As someone who has been using these elves for years, I can confidently say they are worth every penny. Here’s my buying guide to help you get started with the Elf on the Shelf and Elf off the Shelf.

What is the Elf on the Shelf?

The Elf on the Shelf is a popular Christmas tradition that involves an elf figurine who comes to life at night to watch over children and report back to Santa about their behavior. This elf is known for his mischievous pranks and hiding in different spots around the house each morning.

What is the Elf off the Shelf?

The Elf off the Shelf is a fun twist on this traditional holiday tradition. It features an elf figurine who has been fired from his job at Santa’s workshop for being too mischievous. Instead of reporting back to Santa, this elf encourages children to embrace their own creativity and have fun during the holiday season.

Why should you buy them?

The Elf on The Shelf and Elf off The Shelf bring an added element of excitement and wonder to your household during the holidays. Children love waking up each morning to find out what their elf has been up to while they were sleeping. It also encourages good behavior, as children know that their elf is reporting back to Santa each night.

Where can you buy them?

You can purchase both The Elf on The Shelf and The Elf off The Shelf at most major retailers such as Target, Walmart, or Amazon. They are also available for purchase on their official websites.

How much do they cost?

The price of these elves varies depending on where you buy them. On average, they range from $20-$30 each. However, keep an eye out for sales or bundle deals that may offer a better price.

Tips for using your elves

  • Set a reminder each night to move your elf so you don’t forget.
  • Get creative with your elf’s hiding spots and pranks – Pinterest has endless ideas!
  • Involve your children in coming up with ideas for their elves – it can be a fun family activity.
  • If you have multiple children, consider getting one elf per child so they each have their own special elf friend.

In conclusion

The Elf on The Shelf and The Elf off The Shelf are wonderful additions to any household during the holiday season. They bring joy, excitement, and encourage good behavior in children while also promoting creativity and imagination through their mischievous antics. So go ahead and add these beloved elves to your holiday traditions – I promise your family will love them!

Author Profile

Avatar
Liza Jane Maltz
Liza Jane Maltz’s journey into motherhood sparked a profound transformation that eventually led her to become a certified doula, passionately supporting other women through their own pregnancy experiences.

Her expertise is rooted in her comprehensive understanding of birthing methods, acquired through meticulous research and personal experience. Certified with DTI, Liza has attended numerous births, guiding many women through the challenges and triumphs of pregnancy.

Liza's professional background is as diverse as her skills are unique. Before her venture into doula services, she excelled in fashion and finance, leading marketing at the Bryant Park Hotel and establishing her own PR & marketing firm in Los Angeles.

Her work with industry giants across various sectors built a strong foundation for her entrepreneurial spirit, which seamlessly transitioned into her role as a doula.

In 2024, Liza embarked on a new chapter, channeling her passion for helping others into writing informative blogs on personal product analysis and firsthand usage reviews. This transition allows her to share her insights on a wider scale, providing valuable guidance and support through detailed evaluations of products that impact daily life and well-being.

Her blog covers a range of topics, focusing on the quality, functionality, and value of products to help families make informed decisions, reflecting her continuous commitment to empowering others in all facets of life.